Gender and content type in library
weblogs:
An analysis of library directors’ blogs
Agnes Wnuk
Southern Connecticut
State University
ILS680-S71
December 12, 2007
Abstract:
Weblogs or blogs1 are becoming an increasingly
widespread form of computer mediated
communication in both personal and professional interaction.
Some attention has been
given to this general subject in popular and scholarly
writing. This study builds upon
earlier research concerning the relationship between gender
and weblog types, namely the
Herring, Kouper, Scheidt, Wright (2004) study of blog types
and author demographics.
Where the Herring et al. research focused on general blogs
authored by teens and adults,
this study focuses on library weblogs authored by public and
academic library directors
specifically. This research presents quantitative evidence
based on analysis of the
relationship between gender and blog type using a specific
sample of twenty-five library
directors’ weblogs included on Etches-Johnson’s blog
directory. It is limited to library
directors’ blogs in the United States. Results of the study
indicate that there are more
female library directors using weblogs and that a majority
use none of the traditional
weblog type as described by Herring.
There is no indication that gender influences blog
type among library directors, results
which are consistent with some of the general blog
research of Herring et al..
This study recognized general library blogs and personal
librarian blogs as topics requiring further investigation,
and considering the continued growing
popularity and evolution of blogs in library settingsit is both a timely and a necessary
topic of exploration.
1. Introduction
Weblogs have evolved from a new phenomenon to a common
choice of both personal
and professional computer mediated communication. Although
their history is of short
duration, weblogs are found in many settings ranging from
businesses to education to libraries.
There are many issues of blogs that could be investigated,
such as domestic versus
international or personal versus professional. This study
concentrates on the relationship
between gender in weblogs, and weblog content types in
library director blogs.
Although weblogs have become a widely adopted communication
tool
their history is relatively short. Two active bloggers and
blog historians, Herzog and
Winer, credit
Tim Berners-Lee with instituting the original weblog concept through his
“What’s New” page in the early 1990’s (Herzog, 2007, Winer, 2001). In
terms of the current
weblog format Herring notes that Dave Winer himself is “often
credited with creating the
first weblog circa 1996”(Herring, 2004).
The use of weblogs has grown considerably since their
inception. Blood notes that in
1999 there were only twenty-three blogs listed on Jesse
James Garrett’s “page of only
blogs” site (Blood, 2000). In a phone survey conducted in
2003, the Pew Internet &
American Life Project found that two percent of Americans
had created blogs. A year later
the number was between two and seven percent. However, the
study also noted that 11 percent
had read blogs (Lenhart, 2004) Two years later another
survey showed a slight increase
of creators but a significant number of readers. “Eight
percent of internet users, or about
12 million American adults, keep a blog. Thirty-nine percent
of internet users, or about
57 million American adults, read blogs – a significant
increase since the fall of 2005” (Lenart, 2006).
Librarians have been blogging since the mid 1990’s. Maxymuk
and Cohen mention
Jenny Levine’s weblog, titled “Librarian’s Site Du Jour” and
developed in 1995, as the
first blog created by a librarian (Maxymuk, 2005, Cohen,
2003). Furthermore, Levine’s is
also one of the first librarian blogs to win an award. In
2004, her new blog “The Shifted
Librarian” received honorable mention from an online weblog
awards (Edublog-awards.com).
From its formal start just a few years ago, library blogs
continue to grow. In a 2003 study, Clyde
counted 57 worldwide library
blogs,
with 48 of them in the United States(Clyde, 2004) Today, Peter
Scott
counts some 230 varied library and librarian related weblogs (Scott, 2007).
There are two styles of library related blogs: librarian
created and library created. The
first approach includes blogs maintained by a single librarian
using a blog hosting site.
The second approach encompasses blogs maintained by
librarians at a library and found
on the library website. Individual librarians use the weblog
format to discuss library and
information related topics, such as law, science or medicine,
reference or cataloging.
Others consider library science and information technology subjects.
Libraries, especially
public and academic, implement library wide weblogs to present
news, services, exhibits
to their user community and the public at large. Public
library website’s provide blogs for
teens, children and adults, and sometimes a director’s blog.
Academic websites provide
reference, news and director blogs, and tend to be linked
directly to the library website.
It is this common feature of director blogs among all
library related blogs that led to
this being the focus of the study. The issue of gender and
blog type was
chosen because of existing research on those topics in the
general field of computer
mediated communication. Herring et al. found a correlation
between journal blog types
and women, and filter and K-log type blogs and men. Based on
the results of their study,
Herring et al hypothesized that “There is thus a
relationship between blog type and author
demographics”(Herring, 2004). What is missing in this study
and other blog and even
library blog related literature is the investigation of
gender and blog type in library
settings. Is there a correlation between gender and blog
type in library director blogs? Do
female library directors tend to write journal type blogs
and male library directors tend to
write filter or K-log blog types? It is worth studying this
group of library directors to see
whether they, and presumably others, fit into the larger
construct of weblog authors as
delineated by Herring et al. in their research or whether
they have different authoring
characteristics.
Although it is small compared to the millions of blogs
currently maintained in general,
there are continually, if slowly, new blogs created by libraries
and library directors. As
Cohen says it is important for librarians to keep current in
and to use new technologies to
improve their services (Cohen, 2003). This is especially
true of library directors as
leaders in their own library and in the field in general. As
Clyde notes “…the professional
librarian will have to make some decisions about weblogs…and
it is the librarian’s
responsibility to make choices on behalf of others. Just as
for selecting books or Internet
resources…” (Clyde, 2004 p.27) This would also be true of
library directors and the
choices they make in the information they provide in their
library affiliated weblogs.
Of course, it begs certain questions. Should they be more
journal type, more filter type or more
knowledge type? Which are they
currently? Is there a difference between the genders in
this situation?
2. Literature Review
This study deals with two variables, gender and weblog types,
using library directors’
weblogs as an example. To date there is a considerable body
of work detailing gender in
computer mediated communication in general. There are
several studies on the subject of
weblogs in particular, some dealing with gender and others
dealing with content type.
There are also limited studies on library weblogs. However,
little research exists that
deals with library weblog gender and content type issues.
There are several studies of weblogs conducted by the Pew
Internet and American Life
Project which include gender statistics. They deal mainly
with weblog usage and their
relation to internet use in general but they touch on gender
as one of the issues involved.
Linhart and Fox note that: “Like the internet population in
general, however, bloggers are
evenly divided between men and women,…” with 46 percent of
overall bloggers being
women as opposed to 54 percent of whom are men (Linhart,
2006).
In terms of weblog types there does not seem to be a general
consensus in the literature.
Two authors describe weblogs in general. Kirshnamurthy
distinguishes four different
types of blogs: Online diaries, Support group(personal),
Enhanced Column (Individual)
and Collaborative Content Creation (Kirshnamurthy, 2002). On
the other hand, Herring et
al cite four types of weblogs in their 2005 study: Journal,
Filter, K-log and Mixed. Two
other authors discuss library related weblogs. Goodfellow
describes three weblog types:
“1.The Informational/Promotion of library services and
activities type. 2. The personal
comment on professional issues type and 3. The Conference
Blogging for general
audience or aimed at participants type” (Goodfellow, 2007). Cohen
notes three types of
blogs: Informational, personal and informational/personal
(Cohen, 2003).
Although the terminology may differ several of the
researchers use different terms to
describe the same types of blogs. While they have different
titles the Goodfellow
“personal comment” blog type could be understood as the same
as Herring’s “personal
journal” except that Goodfellow’s definition has more of a
professional aspect. Cohen’s
types can be seen as the same as Herrings only using
different terminology.
The Herring et al. study was based on a sample of 203 blogs.
The focus of this study was
on web types. The researcher’s sampling found that the
majority of internet blogs were
Personal Journal Types, at 70.4%, with Filter Type second at
12.6% and Mixed Type was
third at 9.5% (Herring, 2004). Herring also discusses the
analog antecedents of these
types of blogs: diaries, comments to the editor, etc.(
Herring, 2004).
In terms of gender and weblog type research there is one
important study to date
conducted by Susan Herring with other researchers. Herring
et al. considered whether
there is a relationship between the demographics of blog
authors and of the three blog
types discussed above. They demonstrated that in “mainstream
media, in scholarly
communication, and in weblogs themselves, tend to
disproportionately feature adult male
bloggers”(Herring, 2004). Herring felt that this was because
most of the weblogs written
about in popular blog literature are Filter Type, which have
tended to be authored by men
(Herring, 2004). The actual findings of that study found
that the majority of weblogs on
the internet are authored by teenage girls and are of the
personal journal type (Herring, 2004).
In terms of library blog studies Clyde conducted one in
2003. Her focus was on where the
weblogs were found in terms of countries, what types of
libraries created blogs, what
software was used in blog creation, what the aim of creating
a weblog was, and what
compromised content of the weblogs. Clyde did not deal with
blog type and gender. She
also wrote a book on library blogs, but her aim was more of
introduction and compilation
of information for librarians interested in creating a
library or personal librarian weblog.
This study fits into the wider subject of weblogs as computer
mediated communication.
Weblogs provide a forum for two-way communication with their
“comments” feature.
Some weblogs could be compared to a series of email
correspondence with readers
posting questions and weblog authors responding back and
forth. The “Au Courant”
weblog is an excellent example of this type of two-way
weblog dialog on a particular
subject (Courant, 2007). Library director blogs normally contain
a comments section, but
only some are more successful than others in creating a
dialog.
Unfortunately, few statistics or studies as to library blog
types exist. This study remedies this by looking
at the relationship between gender and weblog types authored
by library directors. Since
there are so many librarian blogs this study only looks at a
sampling of library director
weblog types. This research continues the work of the 2004
Herring study of gender and
weblog types but with an emphasis on gender and library
weblog types specifically.
3. Data
This study is based on the analysis of a sample of 24
library director’s weblogs collected
in November of 2007 and culled from the Etches-Johnson
“Blogs in Libraries Wiki,”
which contains a listing of library directors’ weblogs. The
list can be found on the
“blogwithoutalibrary”
webpage (Etches-Johnson, 2007).
To create a
consistent group only one category of library weblogs was incorporated in the
study. Among
academic libraries law library, medical library, reference or bibliographic
related blogs and
among public libraries teen, children or adult related blogs could have
been used. Instead
the common denominator among most library related blogs was
chosen in the form
of library director weblogs.
After reviewing the
different directories that include library and librarian weblogs, such
as Scott’s Libdex ,
Herzog’s Blogbib, “Libarian Blogs and Sites Internet Directory,” and
DMOZ Open Directory
Pages for instance, it was decided to use the Etches-Johnson list.
This particular
directory has one page that is devoted entirely to library director weblogs
without any other
library related or librarian weblog listings. Since it is confined to
one
list the weblogs can be easily located and the research can
be easily replicated. The Blog
search engine Technocrati was also tried but it came up with
only one entry.
While Etches-Johnson
provides 37 international listings the vast majority of library
directors, a total
of 28, were found in the United States. For this study only those found in
the United State
were used. All of the webpages are in English which facilitated in
determining which
type of weblog was being used by the library director. Although the
three Canadian
library director weblogs were in English and could have been used it was
felt that the
criteria should be that only one country be used for this particular
study.
Only 23 of the 28 library director weblogs found in the
United States and listed in the
Etches-Johnson directory were used as samples. Criteria for
use in this study included
that the director’s blog be linked to the library webpage,
preferably accessible from the
library website front page. Only those that were readily
accessible were used. Two had a
broken link and could not be found, one was actually a
library wide blog and one was a
blog by one library director at two different
libraries.
Although there are only 23 library director blogs used in
the study there are 24 directors.
The reason being that one of the libraries in the sample
chose to do a combination “blog”
with the director and assistant director together. Since
they both take part in the blog as a
pair and alternately alone both are count here. The director
was a female and the assistant
director was a male. There were 9 male and 16 female
directors in total.
4. Methodology
Content analysis was used to identify the two variables in
the study, namely the library
director’s gender and the weblog type properties of the
blogs in the sample set. Criteria
were established for placing each sample blog in an
established weblog type as described
by Herring et al.
First, each weblog in the sample was searched for gender
information about the author.
The information was entered into Table 1. Only gender is specifically
studied here
without age or other demographic information. These would be
other variables that are
valid but go beyond the scope of this particular study.
Second, each weblog in the sample was searched for content
type vis a vis the four types
of blog as stipulated by Herring et al. (2005) namely
Filter, Personal, K-log and Mixed.
Two other categories were added in case there might be a
different type of content not
covered by Herring’s four types. These included the Goodfellow
“Conference type” blog
and “other” type blog.
The Filter type blog being defined by Herring as content
including external information
such as “world events, online happenings…”(Herring, 2005). The
Personal Journal type
blog was defined by Herring as containing the “blogger’s own
activities”(Herring, 2005).
Mixed type weblogs, as described by Herring, are those that
show characteristics of both
Filter and Personal type weblogs combined. The information
gleaned from the weblogs in
the study was inserted into Table 2.
In order to facilitate determining the type of blog used by
the directors in this sample,
criteria were established to describe each blog category. Descriptive
examples of the
Filter type include: External topics found on the internet,
links to external information
and commentary on the culled information. Descriptive
examples of the Journal type
include: Personal commentary on local or personal activities,
the word I employed.
Descriptive examples of the K-log type include: knowledge management issues,
internal, organization knowledge sharing issues, discourse
with employees rather than
patrons. Descriptive examples of the Mixed type include: a
combination of personal
commentary on personal or local subjects and on external
issues found on the internet.
Descriptive examples of the Other type include: Any features
that are found in the
director’s weblog that do not fit the criteria of the other
types mentioned above. This
information is provided in Table 3.
5. Results
Results of the analysis of a sample of library director
blogs parallel some of the results of
Herring’s general blog study but not all. Following is a
summary of the results of the
analysis of the library director weblogs in the sample.
Table 1 details the gender of the
bloggers. Table 2 shows the blog types found in the sample.
Table 3 explains the criteria
used to determine what type of blog was represented in each
sample and the gender of the
director who authored each corresponding sample. Table 4
compares the library affiliated
blogs used in this study in contrast to nonlibrary
affiliated library director weblogs.
5.1 Gender
After analyzing the data it was found that the majority of
library director weblogs were
authored by women. The percentage of women to men in this
study was 70% women to
30% men.
Table 1. Gender of
Library Director Weblogs
Gender
|
Number
|
Percent
|
Men
|
7
|
30%
|
Women
|
16
|
70%
|
Total
|
23
|
100%
|
Gender was determined by the name of the weblog author. Each
weblog had a short
description of the author and his or her background under
the title “about”. In a majority
of sample examples the name was obviously male or female.
Two names, Terry and
Jamie, proved to be problematic and more investigation had
to be made to determine
whether the author was a male or a female. Terry turned out
to be male and Jamie turned
out to be female. A Google search of the given and surname
summoned websites that
elucidated the results.
5.2 Weblog Types in
the Sample
Upon analyzing the 23 library director weblogs in the
sample, the largest group to surface
would fall under the category of “Other”, with a total of 18.
There were also a small
number of “Filter” and “Mixed” blog types, two and three
respectively. However, no
“Personal Journal”, “Conference” or “K-log” type blogs were found
in the sample from
the Etches-Johnson library weblog directory page. Results
are found in Table 2. below.
Table 2. Weblog
Content Types
Content Type
|
Male
|
Percent
Male
|
Female
|
Percent
Female
|
Total
By Type
|
Percent
by Type
|
Filter
|
1
|
4%
|
1
|
4%
|
2
|
9%
|
Personal
Journal
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
K-Log
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Mixed
|
1
|
4%
|
2
|
9%
|
3
|
13%
|
Conference
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Other
|
5
|
22%
|
13
|
57%
|
18
|
78%
|
Total byGender
|
7
|
30%
|
16
|
70%
|
23
|
100%
|
The vast majority, or 78%, of weblogs in the sample were
determined to be “Other”. That
is they did not fall neatly into the Herring categories as
determined in her 2004 study per
se. There were two specific characteristics that made these
weblogs fall under this
category: exclusive discussion of the author’s library and
some commentary of personal
life. The “Other” type weblog contained mainly reference to
the library of which the blog
author was director. Four from the sample contained only
this characteristic. Nine others
had one other characteristic, namely that they also
contained personal information as in a
“Personal Journal” type blog. One sample blog also contained
“Filter” type features. The
majority, or 57%, of this type of weblog were authored by women,
while only 22% were
authored by men..
There were two “Filter” weblog type examples in the sample.
One was created by a
female and one was by a male. Interestingly, one was an
university affiliated blog and the
other was a public library affiliated blog. These made up 9%
of the total number of blogs
in the sample. Topics included general library, library
science or technology issues. There
were links to internet postings, webpages and other blogs.
The “mixed” type blog was only slightly better represented
in the sample than the “Filter”
type. There were 3 in total, one male director created and
two female director created,
and they made up 18% of the entire sample. The mixed type
employed a combination of
“Filter” and “Personal Journal” type characteristics. For
the most part postings contained
information from the internet with appropriate links but
they also had a large number of
“Personal Journal” type postings, as well, detailing the
author’s own professional
experiences and sometime even mention of family life or family members.
5.3 Weblog Type
Criteria
In order to determine which type of blog each sample was, it
was necessary to check each
sample against specific characteristics that are endemic to
each blog type. If the weblog
met the criteria of a weblog type it was put under the
appropriate category in Table 3 and
counted as that type particular type of blog.
Table 3. Weblog Type
Criteria
Sample
|
Filter
|
Personal
|
K-Log
|
Mixed
|
Conference
|
Other
|
Gender
|
Dates
|
Criteria
|
External
|
Internal
|
knowledge
|
Filter
|
Conference
|
Local
|
|
|
Criteria
|
Links
|
Personal
|
staff
|
Personal
|
staff
|
Library
|
|
|
Criteria
|
Commentary
|
Commentary
|
Commentary
|
Commentary
|
Commentary
|
News
|
|
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
2
|
|
|
|
F/P
|
|
|
F
|
07
|
3
|
|
|
|
|
|
F/P/L
|
M
|
07
|
4
|
F
|
|
|
|
|
|
F
|
06-07
|
5
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
6
|
|
|
|
|
|
L
|
F
|
06-07
|
7
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
M
|
06-07
|
8
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
9
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
M/F
|
06-07
|
10
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
11
|
|
|
|
|
|
F/P/L
|
F
|
04-07
|
12
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
05-07
|
13
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
14
|
|
|
|
|
|
L
|
F
|
05-07
|
15
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
16
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
M
|
06-07
|
17
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
05-06
|
18
|
F
|
|
|
|
|
|
M
|
05/07
|
19
|
|
|
|
F/P
|
|
|
F
|
03-07
|
20
|
|
|
|
F/P
|
|
|
M
|
06-07
|
21
|
|
|
|
|
|
L
|
M
|
07
|
22
|
|
|
|
|
|
L/P
|
F
|
06-07
|
23
|
|
|
|
|
|
L
|
F
|
07
|
Total
|
2
|
0
|
0
|
3
|
0
|
18
|
|
|
Criteria for determining whether a weblog sample from this
corpus is a “Mixed” or a
“Filter” or any other type was taken from the descriptions
Herring provided in her study
(Herring, 2004). Two extra categories of weblog types were
included in case there were
any weblogs in the sample that fell beyond the Herring
examples. Therefore Goodfellow
“Conference” type and a designation of “Other” for blogs
that do not fall into any
Herring or Goodfellow categories were included.
The criteria and other data relevant to this investigation
is included in Table 3. The
numbers one to twenty-three on the left side of the Table represent
each library director
sample analyzed for this study. On the far right were also included the
library director’s
gender of each corresponding blog sample and the dates when
the blog was active.
Criteria for “Filter” type weblogs included reference to
external information on the
internet, links to this information and to other blogs and
commentary on the information
presented (Herring, 2004). The letter “F” is used in the table
to satnd for “Filter”. Criteria
for the “Personal Journal” blog type included musings on
subjects of personal interest
and descriptions of personal activites (Herring, 2004). The
letter “P” is used to represent
the “Personal Journal” type blog. Criteria for the “K-Log”
included knowledge
management information shared by colleagues or staff
(Herring, 2004). Criteria for a
“Mixed” blog type included a combination of both “Filter”
and “Personal Journal”
characteristics (Herring, 2004). Criteria for the
“Conference” type blog contained
conference information to share with colleagues (Herring,
2004). Criteria for the “Other”
category would contain characteristics not found in the
other categories.
5.4 Comparison of
library affiliated and nonlibrary affiliated director weblogs
For this study only the library affiliated director weblogs
were used as a sample. This
type of weblog is the largest group represented in the
Etches-Johnson library weblog
directory. There were a few nonlibrary affiliated weblogs,
as well, and to prevent any
misconceptions they are included as a comparison in this
section.
Table 4 Library
affiliated versus nonlibrary affiliated director weblogs
Content Type
|
Male
Library
affiliated
|
%
|
Male
Non
affiliated
|
%
|
Female
Library
affiliated
|
%
|
Female
Non
affiliated
|
%
|
Total
|
%
|
Filter
|
1
|
3%
|
1
|
3%
|
1
|
3%
|
0
|
0
|
3
|
9%
|
Personal
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
K-Log
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Mixed
|
1
|
3%
|
4
|
14%
|
2
|
7%
|
1
|
3%
|
8
|
27%
|
Conference
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
|
0
|
0
|
Other
|
5
|
17%
|
0
|
|
13
|
45%
|
0
|
|
18
|
62%
|
Total
|
7
|
24%
|
5
|
|
16
|
55%
|
1
|
|
29
|
98%
|
Five male library director weblogs and one female library
director weblog belong in the
non library affiliated section. These were all of the “Filter” and “Mixed” types, as
described in Herring’s research (Herring, 2004). This
changes the ratio considerably. In
this scenario there are 12 male directors, or 41% of the
total, to 17 female directors, or
59% of the total. Here then the ratio is only 2 fifths to 3
fifths. Also, the number of male
“Filter” type weblogs rises and surpasses the female
director “Filter” type number,
whereas in the library affiliated weblogs they were equal.
This result is closer to the
Herring research, where more general weblogs of the “Filter”
type are authored by
5.5 General
Observations
Several interesting results surfaced during the analysis
process of the library director
sample. There were no blogs in the sample that were older
than four years old. The
majority, or 57%, were a year old. Four were two years old,
one was three years old, one
was four years old and four more had been started in 2007.
This would place these library
director blogs as a rather new phenomenon in the field of
librarian blogs that have been
around since 1995.
The majority, or 65%, of libraries represented in the sample
were public libraries.
Academic were the next largest group at 26%. State libraries
were the smallest sample at
9% only. The majority of women, or 81%, were public library
directors. Male directors
were almost evenly split, at 4 to 3, with the majority
public library directors as well.
In terms of weblog type, one “Filter” blog was from an
academic library and one was
from a public library, so that they were evenly split. All
three “Mixed” type weblogs
were from public libraries. The majority, or 61%, of “Other”
type weblogs were from
public libraries. The next largest group which were
described as “Other” were Academic
libraries at 28%. State libraries accounted for 11% of the
“Other” weblog type.
It is interesting to note that of the two new library
director weblogs created in the last six
months only one was added to the Etches-Johnson directory.
In August, 2007 the Yale
University Library director created a weblog on the library
website frontpage. It has not
been included in the Etches-Johnson directory. Conversely, the
director of the University
of Michigan Library began his non library affiliated weblog
in November, 2007 and it
was posted on the Etches-Johnson directory within in month
This could be the because of
readership. The “Au Courant” weblog is very active with many
external comments and a
robust dialog between Courant and his readers. Yale library
director Prochaska has
received fewer comments to her postings. Also, Courant’s is
a typical “Filter” type blog
whereas Prochaska’s is more a “Mixed” type. This is a good
example of Herring’s point
that men’s “Filter” type blogs receive more attention than
do women’s blogs (Herring,
2004). This seems to be true even among library related
weblogs, if this example can be
taken as representative.
6. Discussion
We turn our attention back to the question of whether weblog
type is determined or influenced by
gender in terms of library director
weblogs. In her research, Herring determined that
In Herring’s study the percentage of general bloggers was
52% men to 48% women. Conversely, in
this study of library director
weblog
authors the opposite is true with many more women authoring the
library
blogs.
This may be a consequence of the profession having more women than men.
The results for weblog type differed from those of Herring’s
study as well. Where Herring found mostly
“Journal” type
blogs in her research
this study found mainly “Other” type blogs.
In the Herring study there was a large discrepancy between
the male and female authored examples
of 20 male to 2 female weblogs.
However,
in her study there were very few “Filter” type blogs in general
as
in this
study. Herring also recorded a minute difference between the number of “Mixed” and “Filter”
blog types. However in her
findings there were manymore men as authors of the “Mixed” blog type. In
this
study
the opposite was true with a majority of women authors to men, or two-thirds to
one-third.
7. Limitations
The library director weblog list from Amanda
Etches-Johnson’s’s “blogwithoutalibrary”
site chosen for this study is not comprehensive in any way. None
of the library weblog
directories examined in preparation for the study were found
to be comprehensive. When
searching the World Wide Web one comes across director
weblogs that are not on any
list and yet exist.
There are two types of library director webblogs and although
both are professional in
scope their placement on the internet and their content is slightly
different. The first is the
library sanctioned type which supports the director’s weblog
directly off of the library
frontpage. The second type is the non-library sanctioned
variety found on commercial
weblog sites. Another study could look into only the none library
linked director blogs
alone. There could be a comprehensive study of all library
director weblogs, regardless of
worldwide location or library affiliation. More studies will
need to be conducted as the
weblog medium develops and grows.
8. Further
Investigation
Many aspects of librarian and library weblogs have not yet
been investigated. The gender
blog type issue could be investigated in law librarian,
medical librarian, science librarian
and other subject oriented weblogs. A general study of all librarian
weblogs could be
studied with gender and blog type as well. Age seems to be a
factor in blogs and could
be studied in library related blogs. Research could be done into
the
effectiveness of
librarian blogs to elicite responses and which blog types
elicite the most responses: Do
public library blogs have a larger audience than academic
libraries? Do library patrons in
certain regions of the country read and contribute to blogs
more than in others? Do staff
or library patrons contribute more responses to library
director’s blogs?.
Many blogs are begun and forsaken, due to a change in jobs,
lack of time, lack of interest
and a multitude of other reasons. Research could be
conducted to see how many library
related blogs were begun and abandoned, and compared and
contrasted to the general
blogs that were begun and abandoned. More questions to be
explored could be: Are more
academic or public library blogs forsaken? Is gender a
factor? Is region a factor? Is blog
content type a factor?
References
Books
Clyde, L. (2004) Weblogs and Libraries. Oxford, UK: Chandos
Publishing.
Cohen, S. (2003) Keeping Current: Advanced Internet Strategies
to Meet Librarian and
Patron Needs. Chicago, IL: American Library Association. pp.49-72.
Popular Literature
Clyde, L. (2004) Library weblogs. Library Management, 25(4/5), pp183-189. Retrieved
November, 18, 2007, from:
http://0www.emeraldinsignt.com.csulib.ctstateu/Insight/ViewContentServlet?
Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles0120250403.html
Goodfellow, T. and Graham, S. (2007) The blog as a
high-impact institutional communication tool. The Electronic Library, 25(4), pp.395-400.
Maxymuk, J. (2205) Blogs. The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances 18(1), pp.43-
45. Retrieved November, 18, 2007, from:
http://0www.emeraldinsignt.com.csulib.ctstateu/Insight/ViewContentServlet?
Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles/1700180107.html
Scholarly Studies
Herring, S.C., Scheidt, L.A., Wright, E., Bonus, S. (2005)
Weblogs as a bridging genre.
Information Technology &
People, 18(2). Retrieved November, 18, 2007, from:
http://0www.emeraldinsignt.com.csulib.ctstateu/Insight/ViewContentServlet?
Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles1610180204.html#6b
Herring, S.C. Kouper, I., Paolillo, J.C., Scheidt, L.A.,
Tyworth, M., Welsch, P., Wright,
E., Yu, N. (2005) Conversations in the blogosphere: an analysis from the
bottom up.
Proceedings of the 38th Hawaii International Conference on
System Sciences
(HUCSS-38), Big Island, HI, IEEE Press, Los Alamitos, CA. Retrieved
November 18,
2007, from: http://www.blogninja.com/hicss05.blogconv.pdf
Herring, S.C., Kouper, I., Scheidt, L.A., Wright, E. (2003)
Women and Children Last:
The Discoursive Construction of Weblogs. Into the Blogosphere, Rhetoric,
Community, and Xulture of Weblogs. Retrived November 18, 2007, from:
http://blog.lib.umn.edu/blogosphere/women_and_children.html
Nowson, S., Oberlander, J., Gill, A.J. (2005) Weblogs,
Genres, and Individual
Differences. Retrieved November 18, 2007, from:
http://www.ics.mq.edu.au/sonwson/papers/nowson-cogsci.pdf
Thelwall, M. and Hasler, L. (2007) Blog Search Engines.
Online Information Review,
31(4), pp.467-479. Retrieved November 18, 2007, from:
http://0www.emeraldinsignt.com.csulib.ctstateu/Insight/ViewContentServlet?
Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles/2540310405.html
Surveys
Lenhart, A. and Fox, S. (2006) Bloggers: A Portrait of the
Internets’s New Story Tellers.
Pew/Internet Pew Internet and American Life Project. July 19, 2006.
Retrieved
November 22, 2007 from:
http://www.pewinternet.org/pdfs/pip%20Bloggers%20Report%20July%2019%20
2006.pdf
Lenhart, A., Horrigan, J. and Fallows, D. (2004) Content
Creation Online Pew/Internet
Pew Internet and American Life Project. February 29, 2004. Retrieved
November 22,
2007 from: http://www.pewinternet.org/PPF/r/113/report_display.asp
Cornfield,
M, Carson, J., Kalis, A. and Simon, E. (2004) BUZZ, BLOGS, AND BEYOND:
The Internet and the
National Discourse. Pew Internet and American Life
Project.
Retrieved
December 12, 2007, from:
http://www.pewinternet.org/ppt/BUZZ_BLOGS__BEYOND_Final05-16-05.pdf
Websites
Blood, R. (2000) “Weblogs: a history and perspective”.
Available at:
www.rebeccablood.net/essays/weblog_history.html
Etches-Johnson’s (2007) “Blogs in Libraries Wiki”. Retrieved
November 18, 2007 from:
http://www.blogwithoutalibrary.net/links/index.php?title=Library_director
Edublogawards (2007) The Edublog Awards. Retrieved November
24, 2007, from:
http://www.edublogawards.com/
Herzog, S. (2007) BlogBib: An Annotated Bibliography on
Weblogs and Blogging, with
a Focus on Library/Librarian Blogs.... Eastern Connecticut State
University. Retrieved
November 17, 2007, from: http://blog-bib.blogspot.com/
Walker, J. (2005) Routledge Encyclopedia of Narrative Theory
(2005). Retrieved
November 17, 2007 from:
http://huminf.uib.no/~jill/archives/blog_theorising/finalversionofweblog
definition.html
Winer, D. (2001) The History of Weblogs. Userland Software.
Retrieved November 24,
2007, from: http://www.userland.com/theHistoryOfWeblogs
Weblogs
Courant, R.(2007)
Prohaska, A. (2007)
Appendix
A. Listing of
Individual Library Director Weblogs as found in “Blogs in Libraries Wiki”.
Retrieved November 18, 2007 from: http://www.blogwithoutalibrary.net/links/index.php?title=Library_director
California
Connecticut
Florida
Illinois
Kansas
Iowa
Michigan
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York
Pennsylvania
Virginia
Wisconsin